Does this ever happen to
you, that while you're
trying to solve a problem
some seemingly unrelated
thought tries to intrude and
you shush it away until
you have an
Aha moment
and realize, "Oh, there's a
connecting thread here"?  
I've been as mystified as
anyone why Dallas
business leaders chose
Mike Hinojosa as Dallas ISD
supe to begin with then
continued to stand behind
him despite some of the
biggest bloopers possible
-- the $120 million procure-
ment card debacle, the
$60-80-120 mil surprise
deficits resulting in a state
of
financial exigency
because Mike didn't insist
on getting detailed
financials he could
understand, then  the
teacher RIFs last summer
even though Mike could
have fired  consultants
instead.

Here's the recurring
thought.
 Some years ago
when a supe in a distant
galaxy far far away had to
leave his post because of
a credit card scandal I
assumed the man's career
was over.  Then when he
was named as the new
supe at a different district
soon afterwards, I
expressed my astonish-
ment to a friend. "He's
compromised," I pointed
out, to which my friend
replied gently, "That's why
they hired him. The city's
business leaders can
control him."
So here's my question for
you:  Did  the Dallas
business community hire
someone likely to fail so
completely in order to put
into place sufficient
justification for mayoral
takeover of the school
district?  Will Dallas ISD
leadership become another
oligarchy of the rich and
powerful replacing trust-
ees elected by ordinary
citizens?
Urban mayors else-
where have cast greedy
eyes on their school
districts' billion-dollar
budgets.  Good luck to
parents trying to effect any
changes in
New York or
LA or Chicago let alone
achieve any accounta-
bility or transparency.

Bottom line:  Dallas ISD
needs a better superinten-
dent--but it's not the mayor
and his big biz cronies.
Will a big warm smile,
smarts, now-familiar
high-energy interview
techniques, occasional
cleavage, plus a track
record which includes
leaving behind a
$25
million deficit and
unfulfilled promises
(although Meria had told
St. Paul she had
5-7
years of work there,
she's bailing after only 2
1/2) coupled with
new
Austin ISD's supe Meria
Carstarphen's job
history of not sticking
around anywhere else
long enough to see if
she actually delivers --
will any of this save
Austin ISD?   We're
about to find out.

My prediction:  
Based only on her
history, Meria will be
gone from Austin no
later than Summer
2012; until then she'll
be away most Fridays at
self-promoting edu--
conferences.  She will
continue her
secretive
ways in Austin including
not posting AISD's
check register online
(St. Paul's isn't, West St.
Paul's is.).
My hope:  Meria
proves me wrong and
matches Pat Forgione's
10 years at the helm of
Austin ISD, eschews
edu-conferences in
favor of working in the
district, and posts
AISD's checks.
CLARK COUNTY SCHOOLS (NV)
Block scheduling costs
Las Vegas  $11 million/year
By Peyton Wolcott
Thur., Feb. 19, 2009/12:07 am
But then, public education ceased being about teaching kids decades ago;
save for a few heroic souls here and there, it's vendor-driven and uses tax
dollars meant for kids to consolidate adults' money and power into a form of
oligarchy, the same concentration of power in the hands of a few privileged
elite that Ben Franklin warned us against:  "We can keep our Republic or we
will inevitably end up with an Oligarchy, a tyranny of the elite."  
What a revelation to most folks it's been to learn that the CEO's of
our largest financial institutions have been almost entirely big
Dem contributors only too happy to go along with Barney Frank
and Chris Dodd and the subprime debacle they created.

A long-time liberal goal: the nationalization of our
local public schools.
 Former IBM CEO Louis Gerstner laid
it all out for us last December in the Wall Street Journal, how this
will happen.  Nationalize standards -- towards which NCLB was a
first step -- then consolidate all districts within a state to a single
district, with another 20  for each of the large urban centers.  As
models go, every one of our largest districts including Dallas ISD
is a wasteful corrupt mess which produces high school dropouts.
But then perhaps Bridger
parents have asked and were
rebuffed
as PTO officers were
at our local high school here in
Texas by then-principal David
Solomon and then-Marble Falls ISD
supe Dana Marable; both school
executives blocked ongoing
efforts to view detailed financials
from our then-fundraiser chair,
Lucretia Lehrmann.   Even though
it's been several years, MFISD still
is not able to produce detailed PTO
fundraiser financials from that
period. All three individuals
are now living and working in
other communities:  Dana is interim
supe in Lancaster ISD, David is
principal at Pleasanton High
School, and Lucretia is a math
teacher at Round Rock High
School.  Although all three have
declined to discuss the lack of
financials, it's encouraging to note
that at least two of the districts
have online check registers:
Lancaster and Round Rock.   Also,
after Marable's departure from
Marble Falls ISD that district posted
its check register online.

Transparency:  A good idea
we can all get behind.
Congratulations to Walt, by the
way, for putting his district's
check register online; that
makes two so far in Nevada.
The block scheduling
bandwagon
continues to roll,
sometimes in spite of the children
playing in the road.
On these pages, I provide
evidence that block scheduling
does not provide an academic
benefit and can even seriously
harm academic achievement in
school. I didn't begin with that
assumption. Rather, it is the
conclusion that arises from
looking at serious research on the
block and academic achievement.
Parents and students are not
being told about the risks when
the block is proposed for their
schools.
Sadly, many administrators don't
feel a responsibility to find real
data before the decision is made,
and often refuse to seriously
consider the evidence once it is
laid before them. Informed parents
find this utterly irresponsible and
bewildering. And when parents
and teachers experience the
problems with the block --
problems that were often denied
as real risks by well-paid
consultants who are brought in to
usher in the block -- the result is
even more frustration at an
educational system that doesn't
really put the students first.
SLAPP suit.  A former partner at Bracewell & Giuliani, Dave left to start Thompson &
Horton, a boutique law firm in the same building and stairwell comprised of "women and
minority attorneys [who] will make up a majority of the ownership of the new firm."  Gee,
what  contracts might this give T&H a leg up on?   
Bill Ratliff pushed through the rewrite of the Texas Education Code in 1995 which
included the weakening of Texas' elected trustees' powers then hung out his shingle as a
registered paid lobbyist and went to work for TASB explaining his new
governance model,
the
"Team of Eight."  To expand on that, he's also got a sweet side gig, the Bill Ratliff
School Executive Academy of Northeast Texas, a "Superhighway," he calls it.  But wait,
there's more!  "The Education Service Center/ Region VIII and the Bill Ratliff School
Executive Academy of Northeast Texas have developed an Alternative Certification
Program for Superintendents in collaboration with Texas A&M University-Commerce, the
ESC VIII Regional Council, the ESC VIII Advisory Committee, the Superintendent’s
Association of Northeast Texas, and the Small Schools Association of Northeast Texas,"
at $3,000 per.
Hey, here's an idea:  Let's collectively raise a hand for this energetic bunch--and gently
encourage them to step away from our kids and our schools.  And, if they really care
about our kids as much as they say they do, given that all four Grand Old Rich Guys of
Education have been made wealthy by anyone's standards from GORGE-ing on taxpayer-
funded public education monies, why not do everything
pro bono from here on out?  
Whadya say, guys?  Are ya in?  We'll raise our hands to say "Bye-bye" to you on your way
out the door, with our most profound and heartfelt gratitude and blessings for your
departure.
---------
P.S.  While researching Bill Ratliff's current lobbying activities (below left), I came across
various names for "Raise Your Hand."  According to the Texas Comptroller there are two
entities:
Robin Hood &
22 'equity' failures
Following the money in
our vendor-driven
schools
U.S. school district
check registers online
I care a lot about our district
and am proud of several of
our accomplishments
during the 2 years I was on
the Board.....I happily spent
hundreds of hours working
on the bond committee
and...I am pleased that we
improved somewhat the
transparency of district
operations. I hope you will
continue to work toward
providing a high quality
education, creating a
positive environment for our
students and employees,
and doing these using as
few tax dollars as possible.

In departing, I offer some
comments and advice.
Accept or reject as you see
fit....

To the Board.
Beware. I believe you are
moving in a dangerous
direction. When a majority
of Board members believe
their role is simply to
approve what the admini-
stration presents, there is a
problem.

When the Board
unknowingly
approves an
incommplete budget
and the administration
resists fixing it, there are
problems. When I, as a
member of the public, will
have faster and easier
access to district
information than I do as a
Board member, there is a
problem.

When Board
members want to
spend the $250k
saved
after the two
refunding bonds passed
instead of reducing the $1.7
million deficit, there
is a problem.

When Board
members think it is
better for TEA to take
over the District
than it
is to make the difficult
financial choices to keep
the District solvent, there is
a problem.

See the pattern?

Diligence is needed,
not complacency.

This said, I do wish you all
health, peace, and the
courage to do what you
know is right.
The nation's 1st  & only daily conservative public education commentary - Dispelling Fear - Giving you Solutions
P E Y T O N   W O L C O T T

How we take back our children's education:
one person, one question, one school at a time.
FAIR USE NOTICE:
This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner.   We are making such material available in our efforts to
advance understanding of education issues vital to a republic.  We believe this constitutes a "fair use" of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright
Law.  In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C., Chapter 1, Section 107 which states:  the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any
other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright,"  the material on
this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.   
If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond "fair use" you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
ATTENTION EDUCATORS AND ADMINISTRATORS:
Every attempt possible has been made to verify all sources and information.   In the event you feel an error has been made, please contact us immediately.  Thank you.
Copyright 1999-2009 Peyton Wolcott

"Walk softly
and carry a big stick."
-- Teddy Roosevelt

"Trust but verify."
-- Ronald Reagan
Just because you can
doesn't mean you should.
H o w   w e   t a k e  b a c k   o u r   c h i l d r e n ' s    e d u c a t i o n:    o n e   p e r s o n ,  o n e   q u e s t i o n ,   o n e   s c h o o l   a t   a   t i m e.
Contact Legal
About
 Press
Wiki  Q & A  
Gallery
School News Quick
Links Best Practices
Commentaries
Good Question
AZ  CA  Kansas  MD  OH  OK  
TX: Education Commissioner
Edgewood
1 2 3 4 5
Cleburne  Katy  Llano  Bremond
RaiseYourHand  Lobbyists
Pearson $1.423B
Akin Gump/Areva/Libya
DC lobbying  TX lobbying
Check Registers  US  TX   Flyer
Ask your district  Set goals/organize
Ask questions  Board Ethics Pledges
Watchdog?AngryActivist Alert   PR
C o m m e n t a r i e s - F e b .  2 0 0 9
ERDI supe
Alton Frailey (Katy ISD / Texas)
versus public  freedoms
First They Came

First they came for the communists, and I did not
speak out -- because I was not a communist;

Then they came for the socialists, and I did not speak
out -- because I was not a socialist;

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not
speak out -- because I was not a trade unionist;

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out
--because I was not a Jew;

Then they came for me --
and there was no one left to speak out for me.

-- Pastor Martin Niemoeller
Gloria from Luling on
sidewalk outside
Walsh Anderson party
at Austin's Iron Cactus
with unnamed man
who was
shy about  revealing
his name
(TASA Mid Winter,
2007 )
'ERDI supes in the news' has moved here
Soghra Najafpour (L)
was sentenced to
death at age 13 for the
first time in
Iran; she's
now 31 --
more here.  
Did principal Robin E.
Lowe (L)  mention
Soghra during her
'Islam 101'  day May 22
at Friendswood  JH?  
Will she mention
Soghra at her new gig
running Houston ISD's
Pershing MS?  
Wouldn't that be a step
towards "raising [her
students'] awareness
of the culture" -- of the
true culture -- in Iran?  
That perhaps Robin's
invited speakers from
CAIR might have
forgotten to mention?  
Oops?
UPDATE:  As of today
no response yet from
Robin to telephone and
email queries.
IRAN: Execution
Danger Alert
School News Quick Links
Jan.-Sept. 2008  
here
Oct.-Nov. 2008  here
The American Superintendent
(Leonard Merrell) as Allan
Ramsay's King George III
 
(Mixed-media collage by Peyton
Wolcott, Copyright 2008)
Wolcott
Peyton
Jan.2009 commentaries here
Hats off to
Jim Van
Overschelde
Wimberley ISD (TX)
Trustees doing
the right thing
1.  End discretionary spending.
Set an example for your staff; let
them know you mean business
about running a tighter ship:
No trips, no conferences, no
meals, no credit cards.  If you want
to learn more about something, use
Google.  Do a webinar.  Read a
newsletter.   No golf games with
vendors, ever.  No chauffeurs, no
rental cars.  Stay home, do your
work and keep your nose clean.

2.  Reduce administrative costs.
Go through your administrative staff
roster and cut every other job,
starting with getting rid of all PR and
marketing.  No advisors, no
consultants. Learn how to really
read a budget.  Put your check
register and all wire transfers online.

3.  Ethics.
No nepotism.  Let your wife and
kids earn a living in a field other
than education.  No board
members' spouses working in the
district.  Conduct all discussions
with vendors and potential vendors
in the open; invite your public to
watch and ask questions.  Throw
away your contract and work year
by year.  Move your chair off the
dais at board meetings.  You're not
a team member with your elected
trustees.  You're not equal to them.  
They're your boss.

4.  No construction.  
If you're the rare district truly
experiencing sufficient growth to
justify building new schools,
splinter off that population and let
them start their own new school
district or charter school.  They
might be able to take over an
abandoned church or office building
for much less than the Taj Mahal
you had in mind.

5.  Back-to-basics curriculum.
Math table (1st grade: add, 2nd
grade: subtract, 3rd grade multiply,
4th grade divide) daily drill.  You
made sure your own kids learned
the basics at home or with tutors;
why shouldn't all children have that
same opportunity?  Ditto for
phonics.  Classical literature.  
History, not social studies.  No
more block scheduling.  Daily P.E.
for all. Emphasize individual effort
and accomplishment.

6.  Attitude.  
You're a public servant, not a Third
World dictator. Practice humility
and gratitude.  Remember when
your employees laugh at your
jokes or tell you you're cool or
vendors marvel at your every
utterance that they're all sucking up
to you.  Remember why you got
into education to begin with.  Sell
your house in the gated community
and buy one in the middle of a real
subdivision like your average
parents and taxpayers can afford.  
Let yourself be driven not by the
latest platitude you picked up at the
latest education conference but by
the same wonderful noble desire to
educate kids that got you into this
field.
nation & 49 states
Texas
b e s t   
p r a c t i c e s
s c h o o l  n e w s  
q u i c k   l i n k s
More "Best Practices" here.
U.S. FEDERAL TAXPAYER
DOLLARS TO  DISD
2000-2007
2000-2001   $   121,951,145
2001-2002   $   137,745,786
2002-2003   $   169,103,740
2003-2004   $   188,618,903
2004-2005   $   188,838,330
2005-2006   $   215,068,567
2006-2007  
 $   217,970,686
TOTAL        $1,239,297,157
TEXAS TAXPAYER
DOLLARS TO DISD
2000-2007
2000-2001   $   204,116,731
2001-2002   $   180,097,229
2002-2003   $   254,465,426
2003-2004   $   199,905,502
2004-2005   $   199,940,243
2005-2006   $   198,907,113
2006-2007   $
  305,839,277
TOTAL         $1,543,271,521
Saturday, February 28, 2009
Texas and U.S. taxpayers have sent
almost $3 billion
to Dallas ISD since 2000
Best Practices  Ethicspledges
Transparency Lax oversight
San Antonio Triple Crown  
Team of 8  Pass the trash
One clue as to the seduc-
tive nature of power is that
once you get some, it's
hard to voluntarily give it up.

President George
Washington gave our fledg-
ling nation a great gift by
walking away from the
presidency after only two
terms -- at a time when
many in America would
have happily allowed him
to be regent-for-life.  He
had the greater good in
mind and heart, and for his
gift we can all be grateful --
and look to his example.

Wimberley ISD trustee Jim
Van Overschelde has done
something commendable
along those same lines by
resigning from the WISD
school board earlier this
week after receiving a
promotion at the Texas
Education Agency.

In an articulate and
thoughtful letter of
resignation, Jim makes
some suggestions to his
fellow trustees of which it
would be wise for all
school board members
everywhere take heed.

From Jim's letter:
Jim Van Overschelde
Way to go, Jim!  
FAQ         ARCHIVES          FOLLOW THE MONEY       CHECK REGISTER INFO      STATE & LOCAL        GOVERNANCE      VENDOR LOBBY
When I first saw the headline yesterday morning that
Illinois Governor Rod Blagojevich had just been
arrested along with his chief of staff, John F. Harris,
on charges of among other things trying to sell Barack
Obama's U.S. Senate seat, my first reaction was
probably not that different from yours, "Oh.  
Illinois."

You know, as in the 3 R's:  prior governor George
Ryan, former Congressman Dan  Rostenkowski,  and
long-time Obama supporter Tony Rezko.  As in, to
quote Matt Drudge, "Crook County."  As in, "Chicago,
Arne Duncan (L) and Rod "Even My Hair's For Sale"  
Blagojevich (R)     
(GRAPHIC IMAGE--Peyton Wolcott)
What's Arne Duncan's track record on
financial transparency?
Given that getting rid of corruption in public education
must be job one for the next US DOE secretary, and
given that Chicago Public Schools CEO Arne Duncan
has deep ties to Chi-Land (he's from there), and given
also that he's a front runner for the post, a good
question to ask is, "How transparent has Arne been
during his tenure as supe of Chicago schools?"  
Meaning, how much has he opened up specific-dollar
CPS actual financials to the public in the cheapest,
easiest and fastest way possible, by putting checks
online?  No pie charts, no percentages, no
aggregates, but real checks-to?

When I went looking on Chicago Schools' website and
couldn't find their checks, I called the CPS PR
department and asked whether Arne had made any
plans to put their check register online.  After
explaining to the fellow with whom I spoke what a
check register was, he said he'd look into it and get
back to me.  Shouldn't be that hard; even though
Florida's Miami-Dade County Public Schools has
fewer students, if we can believe Chicago Public
Schools accounting over Miami's M-DCPS spent a lot
more money last year, $6.7 billion for all expenditures,
all funds as opposed to the $4.6 bilion CPS will admit
to.  I sent the PR guy a helpful
link to Miami's check
register so Arne could see for himself.   

Oh, wait!  Miami-Dade's check register is online
because Marta Perez, an elected trustee, pushed for it
last year -- but all seven Chicago Public Schools
trustees are appointed by Mayor Daley.  D'ya think
they'd risk losing their appointments by pushing for
financial transparency with a Chicago mayor who
controls all of Chicago public ed?  

No response yet from CPS
Perhaps that was the famous "I'll get back to you when
Hell freezes over" time frame.  Or, maybe what the
CPS PR guy really meant was, "It's a long way to
Tipperary which is where we hid the check register
Corruption Capital" and the "Chicago Machine."   As in,
apparently anything goes in Chi-Land and surrounds
that's not nailed down.  

Graft, graft everywhere and not a drop to
drink
Chicago's suburbs have not been immune from graft
and corruption.  It was just over three years ago -- a
year after Gov. Blagojevich appointed Thomas Ryan,
then-supe of Community Consolidated School District
168 in Sauk Village (a half-hour south of Chicago) to a
task force of school administrators to help shape
Blagojevich's new Department of Education -- that
investigators raided Ryan's home and hauled off a
Left: Thomas Ryan (center) in his garage.  Right: Investigator carrying
laundry basket filled with cash.
 (PHOTOS--Southtown Star)
laundry basket filled with cash, ten years of financial
records, computers and a collapsible metal billy club.  
Ryan was eventually indicted, tried and sent to a
minimal-security prison where, presumably without
the asp, he served only a few years of his eight-year
sentence.
SAUK VILLAGE SCHOOLS:
Role played by investigative journalists
A shout out to the Daily Southtown:  The Illinois State
Attorney only began looking into Sauk Village
schools' finances after The Daily Southtown
published stories by reporters Linda Lutton and Kati
Phillip regarding questionable payments made to
Thomas Ryan, his family and school district vendors.
_________________________________________
And earlier this year it was reported that "former
Hoover-Schrum Elementary District 157 administrator
Rosemary Hendricks was paid as superintendent for
the Calumet City school system and another suburban
Cook County school district."  Two months ago, the
suburban Cook County district, Bellwood SD 88,
accepted Hendricks' resignation and appointed an
interim supe.  
(SOURCES--Joan Carreon/ Northwestern Indiana
Times; David Pollard/Proviso Herald; and
Proviso Insider Blogspot)
While a former Chicago Public School
manager remained jailed on felony
theft charges Tuesday, the high school
that entrusted her with its finances is
struggling to recover from a loss of
nearly half a million dollars.  Marilyn
Jenkins-Evans, 47, was ordered held
on $200,000 bail by Criminal Court
Judge Thomas Hennelly, a day after
Closer to home, Tracy Dell'Angela and Jeff Coen of  
the Chicago Tribune reported on something that
occurred on Arne Duncan's watch as CEO at Chicago
Public Schools:
Marilyn
Jenkins-Evans
2006 mug shot
she was arrested on allegations that she stole
$457,000 from Simeon Career Academy High School,
where she once worked as business manager.  
Investigators alleged that she wrote herself 319
checks, forged the former principal's signature and
deposited them in her personal accounts over more
than five years at the school.  "How is this school going
to recoup that money?" asked the interim principal of
the South Side school, Leonard Kenebrew. "That's
$90,000 a year for five years. That could have been
novels. Or microscopes. Or training for the teachers.
Or field trips for the students. It's so depressing."
and when we get it cleaned up I'll get back to you."  In
any event, at press time there was still no response
from Chi-Land Schools about Arne's intention (or not)
to put their check register online.

Here's hoping Mayor Daley will let Arne put CPS
checks online whether or not Arne makes US DOE
secretary; specific-dollar transparency in the form of
online check registers is a terrific way for honest
Illinois administrators and politicians to separate
themselves from  the Blagojevich / 3R's crowd.
More good news from
GCISD:  Frank has volun-
tarily posted the district's

check
register online .  Way
to go, Grape Creek!
Hats off to
Frank Walter
Grape Creek ISD (TX)
Student art mural
At a time when some
administrators are hiring
vendors to paint patriotic or
school spirit-inspired
murals on their schools'
walls, Grape Creek ISD
superintendent Frank
Walter has continued the
time-honored tradition of
allowing student-painted
murals.  
The mural above, by art
teacher
Jack Cavness'
Grape Creek High School
students, is part of a larger
effort in nearby San Angelo
to place more
art in public
places.

More here from GCISD's
home page:
Frank Walter
Everybody wins with
disciplined and focused
student-painted murals
such as this.  Kids have
learned a skill with which
they can make money for
themselves in the future,
and tax dollars are saved.  
Plus the world's a prettier
place.

Here's an aquatic-themed  
mural painted last year at
an expressway by Jack's
students at San Angelo
ISD's Central High:
The seventh period art
class of Mr. Jack Cavness
created a mural for the
GCHS Library and
presented it to Mrs. Franklin
Dec. 12th.  It was produced
in sections with all class
members creating different
parts of the artwork.  This is
quite an undertaking,
because each piece has to
match perfectly when it
comes together.  The eagle
now soars on the west wall
in the library.  Come by and
look at their great work.
Public school checks now online in 30 states!  Total,USA:  437 districts!  308 in Texas!
Hats off to
David L. Cockerham
Espanola #55 (NM)
Online Calendar
It's frustrating for moms
and dads and taxpayers to
call their superintendent's
office only to be told by the
secretary that he/she is not
available. Period.  With no
explanations offered or
given, even when pressed.
Not so in
Espanola Public
School District #55 in New
Mexico, located just north of
Santa Fe and Nambe
Pueblo.  Superin-
tendent David L. Cocker-
ham's
calendar is included
as part of his report to the
board; better yet for the
public, a link to the PDF'd
calendar is included in the
district's BoardBook
paperless
Agenda Packet--
along with their
checks.
Way to go, David & board!  
(Posted 01.03.09)
Above, Espanola students greet
bikers on their "
Run for the Wall"
2008 trek from California to the Viet
Nam Memorial in Washington, D.C.
Texas supe Dana Marable
A-L (Arkansas to Kentucky)
M-Z (Michigan to Wyoming)
Texas school district
check registers online
A-L (Agua Dulce to Luling)
M-Z   (Mabank to Zapata)
Terms & Conditions
Sorry to have to include this; believe
it or not, some groups--God bless them
--have copied my research and
published it as their own.            
MALDEF's 22 Edgewood
districts
have cost Texans
billions -- but show us failed
academics & extravagance.
Can you ID the 15 vendors &
other special money interest
groups at school meetings?
What works:
The friendly approach
Take the Golden Rule with
you when
asking your
schools to post their check
registers.
Flyer with
testimonials addressing
issues & concerns.
Are there enough degrees of
separation between Arne and
Blagojevich for Arne to be
the next US DOE secretary?
By Peyton Wolcott
Wednesday,  December 10, 2008 / 12:02 a.m. -
Updated Wednesday,
December 10, 2008 / 9:59 a.m.
Transparency history
Llano ISD FOIA conviction
Edgewood ISD PD detainment
Progress by
March 2007
1st year ann'y: Oct. 2007
Gov.Perry & Comm.Scott
01.20 News story & 01.22.09
editorial
- Dothan Eagle  (AL)
01.12.09 Editorial Austin
American-
Statesman  (TX)
CHECK REGISTERS
Dec.2008-Jan.2009 here
01.25.09 Editorial / River
Cities
Tribune  (TX) - also here
THE GORGE-OUS GUYS OF TEXAS PUBLIC EDUCATION
Why should we raise our hand for these guys now? We did
what they wanted in 1995 and look at the mess we're in.
By Peyton Wolcott
Wednesday, January 28, 2009 / 12:16 a.m. -
Updated Friday, January 30, 2009 / 11:17 a.m. - New photos & data
L to R:  Sandy Kress, Mike Moses, Bill Ratliff, David Thompson  (With special thanks to Mr. Fish for original image)
Raise Your Hand
Texas
816 Congress Ave Suite 990  
Austin, TX 78701

Ratliff, William R.   
(00020737)
P.O. Box 1218  Mt. Pleasant,
TX 75456
$25,000 - $49.999.99

Raise Your Hand
327 Congress Suite 450  
Austin, TX 78701

Erben, Randall H.   
(00013689)
807 Brazos Suite 402 Austin,
TX 78701
50,000 - $99,999.99

Wakefield, Kakhi H.  
(00062269)
807 Brazos Street Suite 402
Austin, TX 78701
Less Than $10,000.00

Yarbrough, Brian G.   
(00037475)
807 Brazos Suite 402  Austin,
TX 78701
Less Than $10,000.00
Ratliff II, Shannon H.
(00050870)
(512)494-3656 -  Bracewell & Giuliani LLP
111 Congress Avenue Suite 2300 Austin, TX
78701

Long-time school law attorneys:  
Bracewell & Giuliani  LLP
111 Congress Avenue Suite 2300  Austin, TX
78701-4304
Less Than $10,000.00

Active school tech vendors:
Cisco Systems Inc.
12515 Research Blvd. Building 2  Austin, TX
78759
$50,000 - $99,999.99

City of Carrollton
1945 E. Jackson Road  Carrollton, TX 75006
$50,000 - $99,999.99

Invenergy Wind Development LLC
1400 S. Congress Avenue Suite B-330  Austin,
TX 78704
$50,000 - $99,999.99

Not in good standing as of Jan. 28,
2009
with Texas Comptroller:
The Corporation for Texas
Regionalism
1305 San Antonio Street  Austin, TX 78701
$50,000 - $99,999.99

Heaven forbid that the Ratliff's
wouldn't get some of the taxpayer
bank bailout money:
Wachovia Corporation
150 Fayetteville Street Mall Suite 600  Raleigh,
NC 27601
$50,000 - $99,999.99
RATLIFF LOBBYISTS
Raise Your Hand for Public
Schools/Raise Your Hand Texas
816 Congress Suite 990  Austin, TX 78701

Anderson, David D.   (00053708)  823 Congress Suite 900 Austin, TX 78701
$25,000 - $49.999.99

Jones, Neal T. Jr.   (00013745)  823 Congress Suite 900 Austin, TX 78701
Less Than $10,000.00

Raise Your Hand for Public Schools
PO Box 302183  Austin, TX 78730

All "less than $10,000":  
Eschberger, Brenda   (00029854)
919 Congress Avenue Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701

Girard, Charles H.   (00058717)
504 West 14th Street  Austin, TX 78701

Johnson, Michael J.   (00055885)
919 Congress Avenue Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701

Kelley, Russell T.   (00013737)
919 Congress Avenue Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701

Kemptner, Sara   (00057952)
919 Congress Avenue Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701

McGarah, Carol   (00051437)
919 Congress Avenue Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701

McGarry, Mignon   (00012905)
504 West 14th Street  Austin, TX 78701

Sabo, Jason T.   (00052402)
1122 Colorado Street Suite 102  Austin, TX 78701

Waldon, Barbara   (00057030)
919 Congress Avenue Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701
Ratliff, William R.  (00020737)
(903)572-1846         P.O. Box 1218  Mt.
Pleasant, TX 75456

Such a sweet deal!  Found "Raise
Your Hand Texas" then make
more than the average Texan's
salary from this alone:
Raise Your Hand Texas
816 Congress Ave Suite 990  Austin, TX 78701
$25,000 - $49.999.99
RAISE YOUR HAND ENTITIES/LOBBYISTS
RAISE YOUR HAND FOR PUBLIC SCHOOLS                  32024213194         78204

RAISE YOUR HAND FOR TEXAS EDUCATION FUND  12038185778         78204
And, surprise, surprise!  David Thompson (see above) is a registered director for "Raise
Your Hand For Public Schools."

Here's the group statement from one table's participants at the January 28, 2009 "Raise
Your Hand" conference at the Hilton in downtown Austin, Texas for principals who had
participated last summer in a conference at Harvard regarding that experience:
[Raise Your
Hand director]
Bull, Blaine H.
 
(00012158)
(512)744-0044        327
Congress Ave. Suite 450
Austin, TX 78701

CHRISTUS Health
4109 Carmel Mountain  
McKinney, TX 75070
$25,000 - $49.999.99

Texas Border
Coalition
901 Business Park Dr. Suite
200  Mission, TX 78572
$10,000 - $24,999.99

Texas Employers for
Immigration
1209 Nueces Street  Austin, TX
78701
$10,000 - $24,999.99
Are the four Grand Old Rich Guys of Education ("GORGE") of Texas schools public
servants -- or merely self-serving folks GORGE-ing at our kids' education troughs?  
Hard to say.  They keep coming
at us with new ideas such as

"
Raise Your Hand" (more
below) and the Sandy Kress/
Mike Moses/David Thompson/
Don McAdams* "Common
Ground" paper (not to mention
the new "visioning" report from
such 21st Century Skills folks
as Phil Schlecty and Willard
Daggett,  "Creating
a New
Vision for Public Education in
Texas") --but the new ideas
always entail putting more of
our tax dollars in their pockets.  
Vendors,
lobbyists, call them
what you will.  They want our
Mike Moses (center) at podium speaking to 100 or so Texas principals
at downtown Austin Hilton on a school day -- January 28, 2009.
Who are these GORGE-ous guys?  
Sandy Kress is a lawyer and also a vendor's representative/lobbyist for Pearson, the
British-based education giant who profits from the accountability testing that's key to the
No Child Left Behind legislation Sandy's credited as being the architect of -- how circular
is that?
When the Texas public school principals attending the "Raise Your
Hand" conference were told "You are the best and brightest," no one
raised their hand to disagree or to question the accolade.
And Mike Moses (see "Raise
Your Hand for a Hand Out" at
far right
here) and Bill Ratliff
dreamed up
"Raise Your
Hand," which appears to want
to drive the next generation of
drecky unproven edu-reforms
designed to benefit liberal
social engineering agendas
and the vendors who sell
programs supporting them.  
The group's
consigliari, David
Thompson, has, with Mike
Moses, a superintendent
search firm, School Executive
Consulting, Inc.  Dave on his
own is a registered lobbyist
for the
Texas Association of
School Administrators among
others; he collects as much
as (declared) $155,000
annually, from this one
revenue stream alone.  He's
also an attorney with a
lucrative private school
practice--name a MALDEF/
Robin Hood lawsuit in recent
memory he's not collected
sizable fees from--who is
known as the filer of a
[Note spelling and capitalization]
Yolanda Larkin of Brownsboro ISD (left, standing)  facilitated this table's
group consensus statement regarding their Harvard experience at the
"Raise Your Hand" January 28, 2009 conference at the Austin Hilton.
money, despite the fact that what they've been selling us since 1995 when SB 1, the
rewrite of the Texas Education Code, passed has not only been wasteful but also has not
worked.   
*  I am researching a new separate commentary on Don McAdams.
ANOTHER GORGE- OUS BILLIONAIRE TEXAS GROCER GUY?
Whose strings is Mr. Butt pulling?
"Raise Your Hand" if you know the answers to any of the above.  Here
are clues from the handouts last week at the Austin Hilton "Raise Your Hand" (more
below) event:  
NEW: Link: 2009 Texas Ethics
Commission
Edu-Lobbyists
Charles Butt's $1 million
in campaign contributions
How he spent $23,000 of it in 2008:

Butt, Charles        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78209 Self Employed/Grocer $1,000
09/29/2008 G LAMPSON FOR
CONGRESS -
Democrat

Butt, Charles C.        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 HEB Grocery Stores/CEO $1,000
09/22/2008 G CIRO RODRIGUEZ FOR
CONGRESS -
Democrat

Butt, Charles        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 HEB Food Stores/CEO $2,300
03/31/2007 P
CHET EDWARDS FOR
CONGRESS -
Democrat
Pro-Gay Rights, Pro-Abortion, Pro-Illegal
Immigration.  "Led fight on House floor
for
partial-birth abortions."  Pro-taxpayer
funding of ACLU lawsuits.  Pro-1st
bailout.  Pro-ACORN.
First the source of
Charles Butt's billions
"The story of H-E-B began more than a hundred
years ago in a tiny, family shop in Kerrville, Texas
. . . . Today, H-E-B boasts more than 300 locations
throughout Texas and northern Mexico and
employs upwards of 60,000 people."
 
(SOURCE--Microsoft, 2007)   
HEB "operates
supermarkets and food / drug combination stores
under several banners, including Central Market,
H.E.B. Marketplace, H.E.B. Plus, H.E.B. Pantry
Foods, H.E. Butt and Mi Tienda, a Latino-themed
store."
 (SOURCE--Chain Drug Review)
BUTT, CHARLES        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 H.E.B. GROCERY
COMPANY/CHAIRMAN & C $2,300
06/17/2008 P
KAY BAILEY HUTCHISON
FOR SENATE COMMITTEE - Republican

Pro-Abortion, Pro-Illegal Immigration

Butt, Charles Mr.        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 H-E-B Foods/Drugs Inc./Executive
$2,500 04/02/2008 P NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF
CHAIN DRUG STORES
POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE

BUTT, CHARLES        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 HEB GROCERY
COMPANY/CHAIRMAN $1,000 03/11/2008
P COLLINS FOR SENATOR - Republican

Butt, Charles C.        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 HEB Grocery Stores/CEO $1,300
03/03/2008 P
CIRO RODRIGUEZ FOR
CONGRESS -
Democrat

Butt, Charles                SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 H.E.B. Grocery/Chief Executive Offi
$2,300 02/12/2008 P MCCAUL FOR
CONGRESS, INC - Republican

Butt, Charles Mr.        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 H-E-B Foods/Drugs Inc./Executive
$2,500 11/09/2007 P NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF
CHAIN DRUG STORES
POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE

Butt, Charles Mr.        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 H-E-B Foods/Drugs Inc./Executive
$2,500 06/06/2007 P NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION OF
CHAIN DRUG STORES
POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE

Butt, Charles C        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 H.E. Butt Grocery Company/Chairman
$2,300 04/12/2007 P
CHARLES A.
GONZALEZ
CONGRESSIONAL
CAMPAIGN -
Democrat

BUTT, CHARLES        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 HEB GROCERY
COMPANY/CHAIRMAN $1,000 08/22/2008
G COLLINS FOR SENATOR - Republican

Butt, Charles C.        SAN ANTONIO, TX
78204 HEB Grocery Stores/CEO $1,000
03/27/2007 P
CIRO RODRIGUEZ FOR
CONGRESS -
Democrat
According to Time Magazine, "Most Americans, 56
to 40 percent, want a border wall built along
Mexico and America... all the way across. 62
percent of Americans want the military to guard
the border. 51 percent want all illegals deported,
and the border sealed...
(SOURCE--DirectorBlue.Blogspot)
You may have noticed in a recent report by my Austin
bureau colleague R.G. Ratcliffe that grocery store
executive Charles Butt has emerged as one of the
biggest political donors from San Antonio. He has given
more money — $1 million — than fellow San Antonio
businessman James Leininger, who has given $720,000
to state candidates and committees so far this year.
And while Leininger's primary interest is promoting tax-
paid vouchers to allow some students to attend private
schools, Butt is a strong supporter of the public school
system.
The vast majority of Butt's contributions, $785,000, in
this election cycle went to Texas Parent PAC, an anti-
voucher political action committee that was instrumental
in several races for the Texas House. He was the
PAC's single biggest donor by far.
(SOURCE--South
Texas Chisme)
Is Forbes-listed San Antonio, Texas billionaire
grocer Charles C. Butt merely another left-leaning
inherited-wealth activist?  

Or, as some readers have suggested, does he
have a larger scheme -- or schemes -- in mind?

To answer this, first we have to answer the
question:  Just who is Charles Butt?  Could he be
described as being another GORGE-ous Grand
Old Rich Guy of Education?   Given the amount of
money he's poured into trying to institutionalize
children as young as four in pre-school where they
would be subject to indoctrination by their
government handlers, this seems a good time to
take a closer look.  As LBJ used to say, "Come, let
us reason together."
Forbes lowers Butt's rank
Although Charles' wealth has remained constant
in actual dollars ( $2.2 billion ) from
2005 to 2008,
Forbes has kicked Butt's ranking among
America's 400 wealthiest Americans down to 205
in 2008, from 112th place in 2005.

Butt outspends Leininger
The source of Charles Butt's money:  an
inherited grocery and drugstore chain
Q:  Is Charles Butt looking out for his
commercial interests at the expense of
U.S. security -- and, according to Time
magazine, the wishes of most of his
U.S. grocery customers?

Butt, who owns grocery stores in Mexico, has given
substantial sums to Texas Senator Kay Bailey
Hutchison (right), who opposed and de-funded the
U.S.-Mexico border wall.
Senator Kay Bailey Hutchison (IMAGE SOURCE below)
By Peyton Wolcott        Wednesday, February 4, 2008 / 10:00 a.m.
From top, clockwise, Texans all:  San Antonio grocer (HEB, etc.) Charles Butt, House Education chair Rob Eissler,
new House Speaker Joe Strauss (from San Antonio), Senate Education vice chair Dan Patrick, Senate Education
chair Florence Shapiro
ANYTHING FOR A BUCK
More of the folks Charles Butt pays $320,000*
to lobby our Texas Lege to "Raise Your Hand"
By Peyton Wolcott - Sat., Feb. 7, 2009 /1:00 a.m. -  Updated Mon., Feb. 16, 2009 /4:51 a.m.
Raise Your Hand for Public
Schools/Raise Your Hand Texas
816 Congress Suite 990  Austin, TX 78701

Anderson, David D.   (00053708)  823 Congress Suite 900
Austin, TX 78701  $25,000 -
$49.999.99

Jones, Neal T. Jr.  
 (00013745)  823 Congress Suite 900
Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Raise Your Hand for Public Schools
PO Box 302183  Austin, TX 78730

Eschberger, Brenda   (00029854)   919 Congress Avenue
Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701 Less Than
$10,000.00

Girard, Charles H.
  (00058717)  504 West 14th Street  Austin,
TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Johnson, Michael J.
  (00055885)  919 Congress Avenue
Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Kelley, Russell T.
  (00013737)   919 Congress Avenue Suite
950  Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Kemptner, Sara
  (00057952)   919 Congress Avenue Suite
950  Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

McGarah, Caro
l   (00051437)  919 Congress Avenue Suite 950  
Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

McGarry, Mignon
  (00012905)  504 West 14th Street  Austin,
TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Sabo, Jason T.
  (00052402)  1122 Colorado Street Suite 102  
Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Waldon, Barbara
  (00057030)  919 Congress Avenue Suite
950  Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Raise Your Hand Texas
816 Congress Ave Suite 990  Austin, TX 78701

Ratliff, William R.   (00020737)  P.O. Box 1218  Mt. Pleasant,
TX 75456  $25,000 -
$49.999.99

Raise Your Hand  
327 Congress Suite 450  Austin, TX 78701

Erben, Randall H.   (00013689)  807 Brazos Suite 402 Austin,
TX 78701  $50,000 -
$99,999.99

Wakefield, Kakhi Huffaker  
 (00062269)  807 Brazos Street
Suite 402 Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00

Yarbrough, Brian G.
  (00037475)  807 Brazos Suite 402  
Austin, TX 78701  Less Than
$10,000.00
HEB Grocery
P. O. Box 839999  San Antonio,
TX 78283

Gilbert, Don A.  (00030056)
401 West 15th Street Suite 870  Austin, TX
78701     $50,000 -
$99,999.99
Brenda Eschberger was a lobbyist for Philip
Morris, Inc. in 1995.  Eschberger has knowledge
of the tobacco industry’s lobby tactics employed
in Texas.  
(SOURCE--U.S. District Court, et al)
*  (Texas Ethics Commission as
of 2009)
Brenda Eschberger used to lobby for tobacco
interests and now includes among her clients
outdoor billboards; she already holds 41
contracts worth as much as $410,000 thus far,
and the Lege is just starting up.
Brenda Eschberger at billboard convention in
Puerto Rico (March 2008)
$410,000 - Eschberger, Brenda  
(00029854)  (512)480-8444  919 Congress
Avenue Suite 950  Austin, TX 78701

3M Company           Less Than $10,000.00
Accenture LLP          Less Than $10,000.00
Aetna                       Less Than $10,000.00
Air Evac EMS         Less Than $10,000.00
American Airlines      Less Than $10,000.00
Aqua Water Supply   Less Than $10,000.00
AT&T Inc.                Less Than $10,000.00
BEPCO L.P.           Less Than $10,000.00
Chesapeake Energy
LessThan$,$10,000.00
City of Amarillo         Less Than $10,000.00
Collin County MUD  Less Than $10,000.00
Cottonwood Financial Less Than $10,000.00
Credit UnionLeg.Coalition
Less Than $10,000.0
Crow Family Pshp   Less Than $10,000.00
Dallas Regional CofCLess Than $10,000.00
Dell Inc.                  Less Than $10,000.00
Denton County Dev. Less Than $10,000.00
Denton CountyWSD4Less Than $10,000.00
Denton CountyWSD7Less Than $10,000.00
ETX Med
.CtrHealthcareLess Than $10,000.0
EMC Corporation      Less Than $10,000.00
Entergy Texas Inc.    Less Than $10,000.00
First Southwest Co.   Less Than $10,000.00
Fort Worth Chamber  Less Than $10,000.00
General Motors Corp.Less Than $10,000.00
H-E-B                      Less Than $10,000.00
Hicks Sports Group  Less Than $10,000.00
Hillwood Dev.          Less Than $10,000.00
Holt Texas Ltd.         Less Than $10,000.00
LCRA                     Less Than $10,000.00
NTX Texas Tollway  Less Than $10,000.00
NRG Energy Inc.     Less Than $10,000.00
Outdoor Ad Assn TX Less Than $10,000.00
Peter O'Donnell Jr.   Less Than $10,000.00
Raise Your Hand      Less Than $10,000.00
Richard C. Strauss   Less Than $10,000.00
San Antonio Spurs    Less Than $10,000.00
Teaching HospitalsTX Less Than $10,000.00
TX BeverageAssn   Less Than $10,000.00
TWU Foundation       Less Than $10,000.00
Trinity Industries Inc. Less Than $10,000.00
She's also listed by Texans for Public Justice as
part of their "Exposing the misuse and abuse of
the public commons" effort:
July 18, 2007:  Peddling Welfare-Privatization
Boondoggles / Appendix: Texas Social Service
Privatization Lobbyists, 1997-2007 (max. value of
contracts:  $80,000
Yum-Yum:  Products produced by Brenda's client
the Texas Beverage Association include such
ingredients as high fructose corn syrup, caffeine
and low-calorie sweeteners.  Also from TPJ re
the 2005 Lege::
Sin-tax opponent RJ Reynolds boosted its lobby
spending 67 percent.
The soda-pushing Texas
Beverage Association spent $225,000 in the
specials after sitting out the regular session. . .
.
Special Sessions Newcomers - In addition to
the lobby clients that increased their lobby
expenditures, 61 clients that were not registered
in the regular session decided to hire lobbyists
during the 2005 special sessions. Sin-tax
interests again topped this list of new lobby
clients. The
top new client was the Texas
Beverage Association, a soft-drink trade group
that may have helped let the fizz out of junk-
food taxes.
The beverage group paid 10
lobbyists—led by Public Strategies—up to
$255,000.
Here are the Raise Your Hand registered lobbyists -- thus far:
A teacher among
teachers: Rafe Esquith
of The Hobart
Shakespeareans
(LAUSD / CA)
Rafe Esquith (L) with
Recently when I attended a
Charles Butt-hosted "Raise
Your Hand" event in Austin
several principals voiced
concerns about the issues
and problems many
students bring to school
with them; they asked
about additional funding
available for dealing with
such students.
Why do educators
automatically seek more
dollars for dealing with
challenged students when
the richness they seek lies
within their own hearts?
Rafe Esquith, a 5th-grade
teacher in Los Angeles
USD, is daily confronted
with all of these same
issues then some.  
Hobart Elementary's Room
56, home to Rafe's "
Hobart
Shakespeareans," is
situated in one of the
poorest parts of LA.; all of
his students qualify for free
breakfast and lunches, and
few speak English as a
first language. Many are
from poor or troubled
families.  The school is on
frequent lockdown
because of drug traffickers.
The Hobart
Shakesperareans believe
"There Are No Shortcuts."
These 5th grade children
begin to arrive in class at
6:30 a.m. and by 7:00 a.m.
are solving complex math
problems a full hour before
traditional school begins.
They stay until 5:00 p.m. or
even later, and voluntarily
come to school during their
vacation periods. They read
high school level literature
and devour United States
History, learning how to be
good Americans.
Most important of all, these
children are recog-
nized around the world for
their outstanding character.
In addition to scoring extra-
ordinarily high on standard-
ized tests, these students
feed the homeless, raise
money for the Red Cross,
and give performances to
support AIDS research.
These students receive over
$1 million each year in
scholarships to attend first-
rate schools. Oustanding
prep schools know these
students are a sure thing.
The Hobart Shakespearans
performing in Texas (Summer 2008)
Because Rafe succeeds
where others fail
-- rather
than producing high school
dropouts as do many of his
peers at urban schools, his
students attend an
impressive array of
colleges
-- let's listen to Rafe:
I'm hoping that this August
rather than hiring outside
convocation speakers at
$5,000 a pop our adminis-
trators will save $4,970 and
instead show their staff
Mel
Stuart's video about Rafe
and his kids.  It will inspire
and encourage even the
most tired and jaded of our
wonderful educators.
Brenda Eschberger  $410,000
(00029854)  (512)480-8444  919 Congress Ave. Austin, TX 78701
Randall H. 'Randy' Erben    $2.65 million
(00013689)   (512)472-1682   807 Brazos Suite 402 Austin, TX 78701
For a guy wielding this much
power, Randall Erben's  
surprisingly camera-shy.  
I was unable to find a single
photograph of him on the Internet;
the closest was this one (L)  
of his million-dollar Austin house.

Small world:  Andrew Erben (R)
works as a lobbyist for
another public ed group, the
Texas Institute for
Education Reform.  
He also sells houses
Specific immediate
steps educators and
trustees can take to
lower costs:
Edu-Monopoly  Education,Inc  Technology
ERDI  "Financial Exigency"  Credit cards
TX supes travel/meals   Edu-Conferences  
TASA MidWinter Supes/Golf/Vendors 1  2  3
Who else other than Charles Butt
is Randy being paid to lobby for?
Here are Randall Erben's lobby contracts per the Texas
Ethics Commision as of this week:
IMAGES:  Drunk driver wreck:  http://passaicnews.files.wordpress.com/2007/11/drunk-driver.jpg      
Consumer Affairs
reports from  
University of
Phoenix
students
Given the amount of money San Antonio grocer Charles Butt is pouring into the passage of
legislation during the 2009 Texas Lege in order to advance his pet  social causes, this seems a good
time to take a closer look at the company he keeps.   Whether or not one man spending inherited
wealth should be able to control the lives not only of future generations of Texas schoolchildren but
also the finances of the parents and taxpayers who are going to have to foot the costs of Charles'
bills is a good question.  In answering that question fairly, the company Charles keeps -- the lobbyists
he's paying to get his new laws passed -- certainly deserve a closer look.  
Whose strings is HEB's Charles
Butt trying to pull?  Scroll down for
larger image.
INDICTMENTS, SETTLEMENT
In March 2004, a grand jury returned a six-count
indictment against Reliant Energy Services, Inc. and four of
its officers—Jackie Thomas, a former vice president of
Reliant's Power Trading Division; Reggie Howard, a
former director of Reliant's West Power Trading Division;
Lisa Flowers, a term trader for Reliant's West Power
Trading Division; and Kevin Frankeny, Reliant's manager
of western operations—for their alleged role in the
California electricity crisis. All of the defendants are
residents of Texas.  The defendants were charged with
conspiracy to commit wire fraud and commodities
manipulation and wire fraud, as well as manipulation and
attempted manipulation of the price of a commodity in
interstate commerce. The indictments were filed on April 8,
2004.On August 15, 2005, Reliant announced that it had
reached a $445 million settlement with the states of
California, Oregon and Washington, resolving civil
litigation claims against the company related to the sale of
electricity in the California electricity crisis of 2000 and
2001. In March 2007, Reliant agreed to pay a $22.2 million
penalty in addition to a $13.8 million credit provided in a
previous settlement with the Federal Energy Regulatory
Commission.
 (SOURCE--Wikipedia)
Who is Randall Erben?
More about Randy Erben's client Reliant Energy & the
California energy crisis (2001-02)
FBI Director Robert Mueller on the 2004 Reliant Energy
indictments:  
They demonstrate the FBI's dedication to
investigating corporate greed at all levels, as "corporate fraud
impacts not only individual victims but the entire economy as well."

(SOURCE--
ENS)
Then-U.T. Attorney General John
Ashcroft (L) announcing 2004 Reliant
indictments; ass't AG , Kevin Ryan
April 9, 2004:  Reliant Energy
was indicted
"over an alleged
plot to artificially boost power
prices during the state's energy
crisis, becoming the first
company prosecuted for a
corporate-wide conspiracy to
rip off California consumers ....   
Two Enron officials have
pleaded guilty, and a third has
been charged for that company's
complex California energy
trading strategies, which had
sinister-sounding names like
"Death Star'' and "Fat Boy.''
Reliant is accused of a much
simpler method of manipulation:
closing power plants to create
shortages, which drove prices
up.
(More here)
(SOURCE--SFGate.com)
In an effort to save $11 million
annually, Clark County is dropping
the block schedule program at all
but a few Valley high schools.  
Starting with the 2009-2010
school year, students will have
the same set of classes every
day.   Block schedules allow
students to take more credits by
holding longer classes on
alternating days. In typical cases,
the schedule lets kids take eight
classes instead of six.   The
school board and Clark County
School District Superintendent
Walt Rulffes decided to cut the
block scheduling to help the
district comply with state-ordered
budget cuts of $120 million per
year.
 (SOURCE--Fox News5Vegas)
Congratulations
to Las Vegas
supe Walt Ruffles
(Clark County
School District)
for figuring out
what parents
have known all
along:  Block
Walt Ruffles
Money isn't the only problem
with block.   
Jeff Lindsay, a
dad in Appleton, Wisconsin
with a Ph.D. in chemical
engineering who is also a
registered patent agent and
therefore on both counts
knows a thing or two about
scientific evidence, has been
beating the anti-block
scheduling drum for years:
schedules are expensive.
St. Paul supe as Austin ISD finalist?
El Paso supe busy back home
By Peyton Wolcott -  Mon., Feb. 23, 2009 / 5:14 am
02.21.09 NH
WEMJ
radio
interview
podcast  
here
Meria Carstarphen has a lot to smile about these days; not only has her name emerged
as a finalist for Austin ISD's top job, she's only 39 and in her third year as a first-time
superintendent running St. Paul, Minnesota's public schools.  
 For starters, she's in the third year of a three-year contract which her board still hasn't
renewed.  Had that happened here in Texas the supe in question would have been job
hunting two years ago.  Clues along those lines:  Meria's house in St. Paul is for sale,
and there are  some mystery away dates on her February calendar.
  ProAct Search executive Nancy Noeske also has much to smile about; placing Meria at
Austin ISD would mark the second time she's struck gold in placing Carstarphen, having
also helped her land the St. Paul job.  Here's hoping that if Carstarphen is given the
Austin top spot she lasts longer in Austin than in St. Paul.
Meria Carstarphen (L),
Nancy Noeske
Meanwhile, El Paso ISD supe Lorenzo Garcia, another
rumored Austin ISD front runner,
dropped out of the race in December,
citing his family's love for El Paso; he has since become involved in divorce
proceedings.  El Pasoans remain preoccupied with the district's ongoing
corruption problems.
Video here of 14-year trustee Sal Mena publicly
apologizing to the community and his family after pleading guilty in federal
court last week.
Lorenzo Garcia
Questions about that
NAFTA grown-in-Mexico
produce
you purchase from
your local grocery store
have been raised and
published by Newspaper
Tree in El Paso.  In addition to
little Angela losing her arm,
in another incident a toddler
was crushed to death by
truck tires in a field in
Sinaloa; he was with his
teenaged parents working in
the fields because there
was no one to care for him.
MEXICO: 10-year-old
Angela Barraza Lopez
loses left arm to machine
while cleaning NAFTA
green beans
Former El Paso school board president Salvador “Sal” Mena Jr. pleaded guilty in federal...to wire
fraud, conspiracy and taking bribes, along with the man who bribed him.
The hearing before Federal District Court Judge Frank Montalvo was on the docket for Mena’s guilty
plea, but standing with Mena in court was
Gary William Lange, a former executive with two
companies
Strategic Government Solutions Inc. and its subsidiary, ESP.
Lange’s name had never been publicly mentioned before in connection with the FBI’s public
corruption investigation
into county government and at least two El Paso school districts.  
Mena, who served 14 years as a school trustee, stopped on the courthouse steps after the hearing
to read a statement apologizing to El Pasoans for his deeds....
One specific item in the list of overt acts states that on Feb. 14, 2005, Mena accepted $5,000 from
the vendor “as a bribe disguised as a campaign contribution from a political action committee for his
continuing support and vote for Vendo-6 as a contractor with EPISD.”   But Mena’s campaign
finance report for that period shows no $5,000 contribution.
Read the rest of the article here.  Background on this case:
AUGUST 30, 2007:  Court documents related to the public-corruption case also show that EPISD
Trustee Charles Roark
and Ysleta Independent School District Trustee Mickey Duntley
are among the targets of the FBI investigation.   Earlier this month architect Bernardo Lucero Jr.
pleaded guilty to charges that he illegally obtained a $25,000 loan to influence an
unnamed EPISD
trustee
....The investigation has touched various areas of the community and has resulted in guilty
pleas by three people -- John Travis Ketner, former chief of staff for County Judge Anthony Cobos;
Betti Flores, former county commissioner; and Lucero.   A mechanic's lien -- a document filed in
court by a bank -- connects Lucero to Mena's daughter, Katherine Mena, whom the lien listed as the
recipient of the home-improvement loan.   On Tuesday, the
EPISD board voted to terminate a
contract with Lucero's firm,
Lucero/Melendez Architects, citing his guilty plea as the reason.  
(SOURCE--Gustavo Reveles Acosta/
El Paso Times)
PTA/ PORTLAND PS (OR)
Making the case--sadly and
again--for schools to
include PTA, booster &
activity accounts in their
online check registers
By Peyton Wolcott
Sun., Feb. 22, 2009/10:36 am
Jackalin Lillie
You're right, PTA
funds are not
technically part of a
school district's tax-
based finances.
However, in most
parents' minds,
money to their kids' PTA or
band or choir or football
boosters or any other such
organization is still money to
the school.  

As quite often these funds fall
under the schools' general
money-spending umbrella as
dollars are commingled, it makes
sense for districts to find a way to
make these expenditures public.

Had this occurred in Portland
Public Schools with their
Bridger
Elementary PTA funds, perhaps 11
1/2-year treasurer
Jackalin Lillie
might not be in prison today rather
than staying home and caring for
her autistic son.   Perhaps if such
a school had paid closer attention
to accountability and less to being
"a positive and caring learning
environment" someone would
have thought to look at Jackalin's
receipts sooner.  Perhaps at a
school where "teachers
encourage students to be
independent thinks, learners and
problem solvers" Jackalin might
have taken this too literally in
solving her day-to-day wants and
rather than leaving PTA funds
where they belonged instead
splurged on "
$4.20 coffee breaks,
trips to first-run movies and a
$329 shopping spree at
Ikea...[along with more than $100
on cable and another $100 on her
cell phone service per month."
 
(SOURCE--Aimee Gree/The Oregonian)
Bridger Elementary - Portland, Oregon
UPDATE:  Not everyone in St. Paul is enamored with Meria
Carstarphen; also, enrollment's down since she took over -- plus
there's also her reported high job turnover rate.
 HATS OFF:  Austin
American-Statesman for
advocating greater transparency in Austin
ISD's supe selection process; wish they'd mentioned St. Paul school
board's failure to renew Carstarphen's newbie contract last year or this.
LOUISIANA
Why Bossier Parrish
Schools are a great
candidate to become the
state's first district posting
its check register online
By Peyton Wolcott
Tue., Feb. 24, 2009/12:25 am
DALLAS ISD
Was shoring up supe
Mike Hinojosa part of
Mayor Tom Leppert's
grand DISD takeover
plan?
By Peyton Wolcott
Tue., Feb.24, 2009/2:17 am
Leppert (L), Hinojosa
As districts go, Bossier
Parrish Schools seem to have
suffered one image setback
after another when it comes to
their handling of money.  

There was
Albert "Bud" Dean,
Bossier High School principal,
a reservist called to duty in
2003 who returned home then
was arrested in 2006 for
stealing $30,000 from his
school's activity fund.  There
was a $50,000 athletic
overspend at Airline High.  
There have been audits since
2002 calling for tighter internal
controls.   And now, Bossier
Parrish superintendent
Ken
Kruithof "has been under fire
amid a federal corruption
investigation that has ensnared
three school system employ-
ees. Several members of the
school board have been
unhappy with his job perform-
ance, particularly communica-
tion with the board."
(SOURCE--KTBS)

What a terrific farewell gift to his
community Ken's posting
Bossier's check register would
be before his June retirement.
DALLAS ISD (TX)
Q:  Anyone find any details yet re Dallas mayor
Tom Leppert's DC visit last week with President
Obama & US DOE Sect'y/ former Chicago supe
Arne Duncan?  Did Blago drop by also?
By Peyton Wolcott
Wednesday, February 25, 2009 / 7:30 p.m.
Q:  Does AISD need less rock star and more rock solid?
Much as I'd like to know who said what to whom at that
meeting in DC last Friday where Obama, Duncan and Leppert
were all present -- meaning, exactly who was promised exactly
what in return for doing and/or providing exactly what, plus how
much money and when --  we should also be asking the
bigger, deeper question:  Why would a Republican like Tom
Leppert
be interested in spreading Democratic old-style
Chicago ward politics and corruption to Dallas public schools?

Have no doubt, that's what another mayoral takeover of another
urban district means:  corruption piled on top of corruption, so
many layers deep we'll never be able to unearth it all.  
L to R:  Rod Blgojevich, Barack Obama, Arne Duncan, Tom Leppert
The only
reasonable
answer
to why
a big-city mayor
and his big-biz
buddies would
want to also
take on a school
district is the
same answer
for much other
corruption in our
vendor-driven
A Helping Hand-- but for whom?  Vendors golfing
with public school supes at resorts on school days at
TAS/MUS "professional development"  edu-conference.
public schools:  Greed, and corporate greed in particular,
disguised as "partnering" with schools, as golf tournaments
benefiting schools, as edu-conference sponsorships, etc.
Timing is everything
Can it be an accident that Tom Leppert met with Obama on
Friday then Sunday morning
The Dallas Morning News  
discussed Tom's plans to take over Dallas ISD?   The time
and effect are clear:   While pre-DC Leppert's intentions were
only whispered rumors, post-DC they're suddenly attention-
grabbing headlines in the local newspaper.
Bust of Bo Pilgrim dominates roof of gazebo
at Pilgrim's Pride chicken processing plant.
Context:  The Lead-Up
Although the popular assumption has been that big business
and its leaders are dyed-in-the-wool Republicans, a curious
phenomenon has occurred over the past several decades.  

Thanks to environmental laws and anti-business legislation as
more and more industry has gone offshore our U.S. economy
has become more and more not about building things then
selling them but instead about the financial services industry
and our public schools; in most counties in America the latter
are our largest single budget and employer, and for many
banks the local school district is their largest single account.
As this has been
occurring,
quietly and
gradually in the back-
ground over the past two
decades we've seen the
emergence of RINO
businessmen such as
Bo  
Pilgrim wanting to import cheap illegal labor to work in
his chicken processing plants and gave heavily to
Republican candidates who led and legislated
accordingly -- which has led to our current porous
borders and our social services being overrun by
illegal aliens.  All this even though a core conservative
value is tight enforcement of immigration and border
Ben Franklin
laws.  We've seen also the emergence of RINO legislators such
as former Texas state senator Bill Ratliff who worked to strip
elected local school board members of their power with the
passage of his rewrite of the Education Code in 1995 and
instead concentrate it in the hands of a single individual, the
superintendent they hired.  Now, one man or woman controls the
spending of millions or billions and if elected trustees ask too
many questions they are accused of micromanaging.
A quick 3-month plan
for Mike Hinojosa &
the Dallas ISD school
board for staving off
Mayor Leppert:
o Mike shows DISD's
board his two most
recent IRS returns.
o DISD's board stops
accepting money or gifts
from DISD & vendors.  
o  No trips or meals for
any Dallas ISD trustees
or employees.
o  Temporarily defer all
school construction.
o  No chauffeurs, cabs
or rental cars.
o  Give 30 days notice
(or whatever's speci-
fied in contracts) to
consultants: Good-bye!
Where the powermongers would like for this to go:  Mayor Leppert gets to
control DISD's almost-$2 billion purse and dole out favors to his friends.  At most he
might have to answer to a school board he himself appoints, as in New York and
Chicago--big whoop.  Bad as this would be, the next step afterwards would be for
President Obama and our liberal Congress to nationalize our schools.  

Cures
For a short-term fix, please see my suggestions above right (orange box).  Long-term, the
search is on for school and civic leaders with character and principle. Based on conversa-
tions with folks across the U.S. I have become increasingly aware of a growing hunger for
leadership motivated not by self-interest and greed for money and power but based on
character and principle.  Where do we find these folks?  A good place to start is by looking
in the mirror and doing what we can to polish our own character.  
Build it and they will
come.
GOOD QUESTION:  Isn't it
great that America's true
conservatives are waving  
adios to fear mongerering
and remembering the courage
and grit that made us great?
AUSTIN ISD
Meria "Hop-Around
Kid" Carstarphen is
Austin's new supe
By Peyton Wolcott
Fri., Feb. 27, 2009/10:27 am
Meria Carstarphen
1997-1999 National Geo.
Photographer
1999 - Boston (MA)
Intern (principal)
1999-2001 Columbus (OH)
Ass't to superintendent
2001-2003 [unknown]
Education consultant
2003-2004  Kingsport (TN)
Admin./accountability       
Oct. 2004-April 2006  DC
Admin./accountability
July 31, 2006-Feb. 2009
Supe / St. Paul PS (MN)
With Austin ISD's
hiring yesterday of  
Meria Carstarphen for
their top job, the big
question is not so much
"Stand & deliver" but will
she "Stay & deliver"?

Meria's work history: