| H o w w e t a k e b a c k o u r c h i l d r e n ' s e d u c a t i o n -- o n e p e r s o n , o n e q u e s t i o n , o n e s c h o o l a t a t i m e . |
| P E Y T O N W O L C O T T |
| Conservative Commentary - Texas public school superintendent Dana Marable |
How we take back our children's education: one person, one question, one school at a time. |
| FAIR USE NOTICE: This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of education issues vital to a republic. We believe this constitutes a "fair use" of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C., Chapter 1, Section 107 which states: the fair use of a copyrighted work, including such use by reproduction in copies or phonorecords or by any other means specified by that section, for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research, is not an infringement of copyright," the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond "fair use" you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. |
| ATTENTION EDUCATORS AND ADMINISTRATORS: Every attempt possible has been made to verify all sources and information. In the event you feel an error has been made, please contact us immediately. Thank you. |
| Copyright 1999-2009 Peyton Wolcott |

| Britain's King George III once ruled our country; despotism by those with power does not last. Public school superintendents would do well to remember this lesson from history. |

| HOME |
| more and more time at our daughter's school. When you spend a lot of time at your kid's school, you notice things, including apparent discrepancies of all sorts such as the district saying one thing and acting another. As PTO officers people brought us their questions about our primary fund raiser, the sale of personalized bricks for a walkway. Our attempts to obtain detailed financials from our bricks chair and then from the high school principal and then the district's superintendent were thwarted and we never received them despite the questions from the community. This was at first awkward then perplexing; why the secrecy? Folks also came to me asking about programs the same superintendent was purchasing, and the conditions under which they were purchased. Also, this being a small town, there were many questions about the superintendent's frequent absences to attend conferences. There were other things going on. A beautiful elementary secretary with cute kids and a handsome husband who was assistant principal at the high school wound up going to jail over some missing book fair money; many of us wondered why there weren't stronger internal controls as in business as such controls would have protected this nice family which must now live with this in their history. (This by the way was the single event which drove home to me the importance of strong internal controls including over all aspects of cash handling in our public schools. At all fund raisers I was privileged to be part of I insisted that we have two people count the money, then sign the sealed cash envelope together over the back flap, and deposit it immediately. This is still a practice I recommend as it protects everyone.) CNN came to town to investigate fourth-grade boys having oral sex -- in the classroom with the teacher present -- and there was some confusion over whether this had been reported properly or not by the superintendent. There were questions about the real dropout number at our local high school, plus discipline issues, plus rumors from trusted local sources about drug usage; students going to school in the morning looked like they were coming home from a rock concert. As a fan of LA Unified teacher Rafe Esquith and his Hobart Shakespeare- ans -- a great example of better teaching is needed rather than more money which shows us that kids thrive in a classical environment in which vendors' drecky curriculums take a distant back seat -- I was disappointed at the high school's low expectations for students. It was in this environment and time that I filed my first public information act request, simply to learn some facts for myself about the goofy-to-us-parents programs (we knew for example that little kids don't learn about honesty by putting the word up on a billboard). Imagine my surprise when the superin- tendent tried to charge me $426. As one friend put it, "What are they trying to hide?" Eventually I spent a year lobbying the superintendent, the then-administration, then-board and then-state comptroller to bring the Texas School Performance Review Audit to the district, Marble Falls ISD; Comptroller Carole Strayhorn announced that she was bring it to town on December 10, 2002, and you can read the findings here, including the need at that time for stronger internal controls in the district. That superintendent was Dana Marable, and I am very grateful to her for teaching me so much, including the need for transparency of all sorts at all levels and the importance of direct and honest communication. Marble Falls ISD's leadership is now committed to transparency; gone are the days of private board trainings Dana facilitated at remote ranches, notices for which were posted only on the front door of the administration building rather than the district's website. Such is MFISD's new commitment to transparency that the district was one of the first 30 districts in Texas to voluntarily post its check register online. What follows are my ongoing attempts to learn more from Dana about why she did what she did. LBJ used to say, "Come, let us reason together." It is my hope that by our reasoning together we will be able to make sure that our public schools remain strong, free and locally governed. More here regarding the groups I helped organize at that time. Here's the Austin-American Statesman article about the little boys: |
| Why there's an entire page on one Texas public school supe By Peyton Wolcott January 21, 2009 |
| Many years ago when we returned to Texas it was my intent to garden and to finally be able to spend time on my poetry and volunteer at my daughter's school, something I'd not been able to do much of previously. |

| My backyard in fall with Bradford flowering pears and not a lick of homemade mulch. |
| Maybe if my husband hadn't thought making homemade mulch too messy things would have turned out differently. He also liked to garden, and between |
| LONE FINALIST DANA MARABLE PASSED OVER FOR DEL RIO INTERIM Hiring of interim super postponed By Jennifer Killin Del Rio News-Herald Published June 27, 2008 The public school board did not hire an interim superintendent Thursday night. After opening the San Felipe Del Rio Consolidated Independent School District Board of Trustees meeting, president Raymond Meza took the panel behind closed doors for more than three hours. “Because the superintendent search has been delayed, I feel it is in the best interest of the district to hire a superintendent,” said Meza immediately before the board entered closed session. Dr. Dana Marable, who holds a doctorate in curriculum and instruction from Texas A&M, was the sole candidate interviewed. Since 1993 Marable has held superinten- dent posts with the Longview, Marble Falls and Medina Valley school districts, according to her resume. She is also listed as the interim superinten- dent with the Temple Independent School District. When the board returned at 10:15 p.m., vice president Stanley Blackstone announced the panel would revisit the issue when all board members are present. “I want to make it perfectly clear we do not procrastinate; we are methodical,” said Blackstone. Three board members were absent – Dr. Fernando Quiz was teaching at Sul Ross State University in Eagle Pass, Sandie Bostick is out of the country on a job assignment and a message left for Joe David Zuniga on his cell phone was not returned by press time. Blackstone said the board decided to wait on a decision until everyone is present and given a chance to vote. He said the board might also look at other candidates for the interim position. Thursday’s meeting came on the heels of an announcement from assistant superintendent of instruction Julio Ramos that he would be retiring at the end of July. Though rumors circulated that Ramos was contemplating retirement, he did not officially notify the district until this week. Roberto “Bobby” Fernandez announced earlier this year his plans to retire by the end of December, but has said he would leave sooner if a replacement was found. Either way, his contract will be paid through December. Fernandez was also on Thursday’s agenda as a possible consultant to the interim, but no action was taken on that motion. A board meeting is tentatively set for July 9 to interview other interim candidates. www.delrionewsherald. com/story.lasso? ewcd=0d037c2dbca17282 |

| Fourth-Graders Reprimanded for Lewd Acts (Boys accused of performing oral sex on each other) Austin American-Statesman Tuesday, March 26, 2002 By Janet Jacobs and Jonathan Osborne MARBLE FALLS -- Police are investigating allegations that five fourth-grade boys performed oral sex on one another during class at least twice at Marble Falls Elementary School. School officials confirm that the incidents took place and that they are treating the acts as lewd behavior. The boys were suspended for a day, have been put in alternative classes for 10 days and will receive counseling, said Superintendent Dana Marable. "It was a dare," Marable said. However, at least one mother, who asked not to be identified to protect her son's identity, said the acts were done under threat. "My boy didn't want to, and the other boys threatened him if he didn't," she said. In interviews with police, the boys -- all ages 9 and 10 -- admitted the acts took place last fall and again in February, said Marble Falls police Capt. Robert Sooter. Marable said the acts took place during a free reading time, when everyone in the classroom, including the teacher, is supposed to be reading. The boys had retreated to beanbag chairs in the back of the classroom and were using their coats to hide from the teacher, the parent said. "The little boys didn't do it in front of the teacher," Marable said. "They hid." A child in the class told the teacher about the sex acts March 7, two days before spring break. The boys were suspended March 8. When they returned from spring break March 18, they were placed in alternative education. Police said they learned about the incident March 18. School officials said they notified authorities March 8, in compliance with a Texas law requiring that abuse incidents be reported within 48 hours. "All authorities have been notified in accordance with the letter of the law," said Marble Falls Elementary Principal Steve Shroft. Police are concerned about three things: whether any of the boys used coercion and might be charged with a crime; whether the teacher or school officials were negligent or were slow to report the incidents; and whether the boys were re-enacting behavior they had learned elsewhere. "Obviously, this is some kind of learned behavior, and it's our job to learn where it came from," Sooter said. Amanda Van Hoozer, director of program services for the Children's Advocacy Center in Austin, said it's possible that one boy is more sexually advanced than the others and is sharing this knowledge. But, she said, a history of sex abuse is a more likely explanation. "Some kids are really precocious," Van Hoozer said. "They know a lot more than other kids. They've seen it in a magazine, and they've decided to try it out for themselves. But if these kids are just normal, average 10-year-olds, most 10-year-olds have not been exposed to this. If they are sexually acting out . . . you certainly want to look at what's going on because it is indicative of abuse." Van Hoozer said another child in the same circle of friends might have taught the acts to the boys. "I think it's definitely a red flag that a child somewhere within this network of kids has been abused," she said. "But again, you have to stress that it may not be any of these kids." Officials with the Texas Department of Protective and Regulatory Services, which investigates allegations of child abuse, said they are aware of the situation but have not opened an investigation. "At this point, it doesn't appear to have been any neglect or abuse by the caregiver, because it was child on child," said Marla Sheely, spokeswoman for the agency. "We're still following it. We're still looking over the whole issue of supervision." The teacher, who was not identified by school officials, is still teaching the class, and there have been no changes of policy, Marable said. "I'm sure that particular teacher has changed her policy," she said. |
| 2002-2006 Timeline On Dec. 10, 2002 then- Texas Comptroller Carole Strayhorn announced she was bringing the TSPR audit to Marble Falls ISD; within 10 business days then-MFISD superinten- dent Dana Marable had announced her resigna- tion as had assistant supe Cynthia Clinesmith; the following spring the three-longest serving trustees (Dale Bergman- 15 yrs, Linda Ross-11 yrs, and Don Sherman-6 yrs) did not seek reelection. A year or so later our then- business manager retired then went to work for Dana at her next post, Longview ISD. |

| Then-Longview ISD supe Dana Marable "speaks about the recent fights at Longview High School with parents and concerned community members" on Feb. 9, 2006. (PHOTO/Luisa Morenilla/News-Journal) |
| September 25, 2006 Re-Sent November 11, 2007 Dana Marable, Longview ISD Dana, in the course of my work I receive a great number of reports; some are easily verified and others are not. In the event I have stated any of the following incorrectly, please let me know what is factually incorrect and supply factual support for your assertions so that I may correct the commentary I am preparing which will incorporate some or all of the following. Departure from Longview ISD Resignation Letter (Texas Public Information Act) Dana, please send me a copy of your resignation letter submitted to the Longview ISD board of trustees. Because this information is for sharing with the public on my website and for publication in my book, I expect all public records fees to be waived; you could PDF this document via email. Receipt/Response as of 01.21.09: None. Contract Buyout Document (Texas Public Information Act) Also, please send me a copy of any document signed reflecting the amount of all monies you are being paid to leave Longview ISD; this amount is commonly referred to as a "contract buyout." Again, because this information is for sharing with the public on my website and for publication in my book, I expect all public records fees to be waived; you could most cheaply PDF this document via email. Receipt/Response as of 01.21.09: None. Contract Buyouts - Three School Districts As I understand it Marble Falls ISD trustees had to buy out your MFISD contract and now Longview's trustees are having to buy out your LISD contract there; is this truth or rumor? Further, it is my understanding that such a buyout also occurred at Medina Valley ISD prior to your employment in Marble Falls. Is this truth or rumor? If not true, which part or parts is/are not true? If the foregoing is true, as has been reported to me, to have had your employment contracts bought out at three school districts in a row is unfortunate for all concerned, most especially the school children, their parents and taxpayers. Based on property records including you on the other hand appear to have bought ranches with your buyouts; these are the reports I have received from individuals in each of these school districts. Would you please comment on the foregoing, what some have called an unfortunate string of events. Also, would you please comment on the apparent situation with your buying and selling of ranches as you move across the state. Speaking of which, how appropriate do you feel now, from the perspective of years and history, it was for you to host board retreats at your ranch for Marble Falls ISD trustees? Have you since continued this practice? Receipt/Response as of 01.21.09: None. TSPR Audit Findings - MFISD Dana, would you please comment on the fact that the April 2004 Texas School Performance Review Audit of Marble Falls ISD found the following, which occurred during your tenure as MFISD superintendent: "MFISD has weaknesses in its internal controls for cash management and other financial areas." "Student graduation rates are below state and regional levels." "MFISD does not effectively develop, manage or monitor contracts." Also, could you please give some insight from the perspective of time passed why you resisted the TSPR audit? And why you resigned from your employment at MFISD within ten (10) business days of Comptroller Strayhorn's announcement that she was bringing the TSPR audit to MFISD? That both you and your assistant superintendent announced your resignations within ten business days of the Comptroller's announcement was very interesting and any insights you might have are most welcome. Response as of 01.21.09: None. MF Elementary School Incident (March 2002) Dana, would you please comment on your reporting of the following events as reported by the Austin American-Statesman on March 26, 2002: "A child in the class told the teacher about the sex acts March 7, two days before spring break. The boys were suspended March 8. When they returned from spring break March 18, they were placed in alternative education. Police said they learned about the incident March 18. School officials said they notified authorities March 8, in compliance with a Texas law requiring that abuse incidents be reported within 48 hours." As I understand it, the proper authorities were told of the incident not within 48 hours but 11 days later. To what do you ascribe this confusion regarding how this event was reported? Further, it is my understanding that while "school officials" asserted the incident had been reported properly on March 8, within 48 hours, there is no substantiation available to back up such an assertion. Do you have any substantiation at this time to back up the assertion that the incident was reported to authorities on March 8 as required by law? Response as of 01.21.09: None. MF High School Bricks Fund Raiser Financials Some years ago during your tenure at MFISD the PTO at the high school had a fund raiser; citizens paid for personalized bricks which were later used in walkways at the high school. Unfortunately, the bricks chair did not choose to share financial records with the rest of the PTO leadership; folks who'd mailed in their checks and cash were complaining to the leadership that they had sent in their money but did not receive their bricks. Yet when the PTO leadership pressed to view those financials, the administration blocked all of our efforts. When I filed a public records request several years later, there were still no financials on record for that time period. Wondering how you as chief administrator would choose to explain this apparent pattern at MFISD of, as TSPR put it, "weaknesses in ... internal controls for cash management and other financial areas." One of the wonderful things about this life is that we can use difficult situations to become learning experiences, wondering what if anything you feel you learned from this one, with an emphasis on the fact that while you were employed at MFISD as chief administrator when several parents tried to help the district strengthen internal controls for cash management they were rebuffed again and again; would very much appreciate your perspective from a distance of several years on this situation and what if anything you might do differently now. How are you strengthening internal controls at Temple ISD, for example? Response as of 01.21.09: None. Temple ISD online check register Speaking of transparency, your predecessor at Temple ISD, Beto Gonzalez, had spoken to me about putting TISD's check register online. What if anything are you doing to put TISD's check register online? As you may or may not be aware, there are at least 69 school districts in Texas, including the two largest, who are posting their check registers online now. Also, TEA has been online since February. Did you ever consider posting Longview ISD's check register online? Response as of 01.21.09: "As interim superintendent, I have not found an immediate plan for posting the TISD check register online." Temple ISD credit cards / PEIMS 701 code expenses Along these transparency lines, do you have a TISD credit card of any kind including "Procurement Cards" or "P-Cards," etc.? In any event, have you considered posting all of your PEIMS 701 code expenses online so that your parents and taxpayers may see how you are spending TISD's monies? It may well be that your 701 code expenses are minimal; I was surprised in viewing your expenses at MFISD to see how many education conferences you attended. The valet parking charges were especially a bit surprising at a time when schoolchildren in MFISD schools were participating in fundraisers to purchase basic items. Also surprising were hotel room fees for conferences in Austin and San Antonio, just an hour or ninety minutes away. Wondering how the valet parking charges and hotel room fees are "For children." Here again there is likely a perfectly reasonable explanation, and perhaps you are attending fewer conferences away from the district in your present employment. Response as of 01.21.09: "I do NOT have a credit card nor did I have one in Longview or Marble Falls." Source of "Ph.D." Title Dana, from which institution and when did you receive your "Ph.D." title and what was the title and subject of your dissertation? Response as of 01.21.09: "All three of my degrees are from Texas A&M University, College Station, TX. and my dissertation is on file in the college library." Could you please send me a copy of such dissertation? Receipt/Response as of 01.21.09: No. Thank you for your assistance, and wishing you all the best. Peyton Wolcott Horseshoe Bay, Texas www.peytonwolcott.com |
| Dana Marable, Longview ISD |
| Dana Marable, Marble Falls ISD |
| deer jumping the fence when they weren't eating everything we put out including "deer proof" plants -- which they looked at then licked their chops and said to themselves, "Lunch!" -- he took over more and more of the gardening and I started spending |
| November 11, 2007 Dana Marable, - Temple ISD Dana, hope this finds you well and enjoying your tenure in Temple ISD. The following are for the book I'm writing on public education-related issues and/or for publication on my website (URL below). Many of these were originally sent to you in September 2006 while you were still employed by Longview ISD; perhaps you have been busy winding up your exit from Longview ISD as I have not yet received a response from you. Presumably things have settled down a bit for you by now and you will have time to respond. I do have some more questions but these will get the ball rolling. Wishing you all the best. Peyton Wolcott Horseshoe Bay, Texas www.peytonwolcott.co m |
| Temple ISD |
| Del Rio ISD |
| Lancaster ISD |
| My queries to Dana Marable; Responses in red below: |
| November 12, 2007 Dear Ms. Wolcott: I have never received this request. I am not sure why I did not receive it. I will respond within a few days to all your question; however, I am about to leave for a meeting and will get back to you asap…… ……….dana marable |
| November 20, 2007 (eight days later) Dear Ms. Wolcott: The Temple Indepen- dent School District does not have docu- ments responsive to any of your requests, and certainly the Texas Public Informa- tion Act does not require a governmen- tal entity to respond to inquiries-------(how- ever, I do not mind telling you that I do NOT have a credit card nor did I have one in Longview or Marble Falls. Also, as interim superinten- dent, I have not found an immediate plan for posting the TISD check register online. All three of my degrees are from Texas A&M University, College Station, TX. and my dissertation is on file in the college library.) Regarding documents that may be in the possession of other school districts, such as Longview ISD, Marble Falls ISD or Medina Valley ISD, I would recommend that you contact their officer of public information. They will have records responsive to your inquiries, which should clarify the factual inaccuracies within your communi- cation ………….Dana S. Marable |
| Dana's responses |
| My follow up to Dana--request for clarification November 21, 2007 Dana, thank you for responding. You mention "factual inaccuracies." What might these be? Resending these questions below for one reason: to extend to you another opportunity to clear up these outstanding issues before sharing them with a broader audience. Also, readers have raised other issues such as your interactions with the community, and discipline issues with high schoolers. Disappointing that you have basically refused to answer some simple, direct questions yourself. Wishing you all the best. Peyton Wolcott www.peytonwolcott.co m Response as of 01.21.09: None. |
| DANA MARABLE DROPS OUT OF RUNNING FOR TEMPLE TOP JOB School chief pulls out; Marable not on list of candidates by Tammy Leytham - Temple Daily Telegram Staff Writer Published April 3, 2008 2276 Views The interim superin- tendent for the Temple school district confirmed Wednesday that she has with- drawn her name as a candidate for the superintendent position. “I was given the opportunity to withdraw my name,” said Dr. Dana Marable, who has served in the interim position since September 2007. “I did that Monday.” The school board announced that it narrowed the list of candidates to five and would select one finalist at the next meeting on Tuesday. That person will be hired at the May 1 meeting, according to the board’s timeline. TISD board president Steve Wright said the list had been narrowed to two candidates, but denied that Dr. Marable was asked to remove her name from the list. “She has not been asked,” he said. Dr. Marable came out of retirement to take the position at TISD and said she has no plans for when her stint at TISD ends at the end of April. “I don’t know if they’ll ask me to stay on after that,” she said. She said she has enjoyed working in the school system. “It’s been a wonderful experience,” Dr. Marable said. “I can’ t tell you how much I’ve enjoyed it.” She said she had learned a lot, and “hopefully, I’ve left some good footprints for whoever follows me.” Regina Baird, spokeswoman for the TISD, confirmed Dr. Marable removed her name as a candidate. “I have faith that the board is diligently searching and believe they will choose whoever will be the best fit for our district,” she said. The TISD board of trustees was scheduled to discuss the final candidates in executive session during a special called meeting Wednesday night, Ms. Baird said. |
| Lancaster ISD superintendent [Larry Lewis above] requests public hearing to address allegations 12:00 AM CST on Friday, Dec. 19, 2008 By KATHY A. GOOLSBY The Dallas Morning News Lancaster schools Superintendent Larry Lewis came out fighting Thursday. Two weeks after board members notified Dr. Lewis of their intent to terminate his contract, the superintendent requested a public hearing to answer allegations against him. "We wouldn't be asking for a hearing if we didn't think we could defend ourselves," said Neal Adams, Dr. Lewis' attorney. "We believe we will prevail and Larry will continue to fulfill his contract with the Lancaster Independent School District." The request was filed through the state's education commissioner. Dr. Lewis has been on paid leave since mid-October. His annual salary is $197,600. The district received the notice on the same day that board members hired an interim superintendent. In July, the board hired an attorney to look into allegations raised by board President Carolyn Morris, including that Dr. Lewis withheld information from board members and tampered with their mail. The investigation later was expanded to include financial issues. The inquiry found that in addition to withholding a preliminary state audit report from board members, Dr. Lewis also made illegal zero-interest loans and advances of district money to employees. The investigation also found that he paid cash awards to employees without authority and proper funding and failed to inform the board about 18 employees hired at middle and high schools but not included in the budget. The investigation concluded that Dr. Lewis "abused his position, committed unauthorized and illegal acts, was dishonest in this investigation, abdicated his leadership duties, and repetitively failed to notify the board about critical information." The report did not address the allegations of mail tampering. Mr. Adams said Dr. Lewis asked for a public hearing because he has nothing to hide. "If we need to have this hearing behind closed doors, then it's my experience that we need to be talking about something besides a hearing," Mr. Adams said. He said he is working with the school board's attorney to choose a school law attorney to hear the case. If the two sides cannot come to an agreement on the hearing officer, Education Commissioner Robert Scott will appoint one. The officer must hear the case and provide a ruling within 60 days, but Mr. Adams said the law allows for a 45-day extension. He anticipates asking for the extension, with the hearing taking place sometime in March. Don Henslee, the board's attorney, said the trustees must approve any extensions. "I have no idea whether they'll approve an extension. That will be up to them," he said. Also on Thursday, school trustees hired Dana Marable as the district's interim superintendent. Dr. Marable is the former superintendent of the Medina Valley, Marble Falls and Longview school districts, and last year served as interim superintendent in the Temple school district. She began her education career as a classroom teacher in 1970. "I want to make a difference and I think there are some good things in Lancaster that we can capitalize on," Dr. Marable said. The board approved her appointment in a 5-1 vote, pending negotiation of a financial agreement. Trustee Marie Elliott cast the dissenting vote, and trustee Ed Kirkland did not attend the meeting. Dr. Marable will begin in Lancaster after the winter break. |

| [Hired to replace Larry Lewis as interim Dec. 2008] |


| Marble Falls High School |
| TSPR audit findings (Marble Falls ISD) here |
| Questions? Please call Lancaster ISD (972) 218 - 1400 |